I don’t know if anyone else has noticed but with the demise of the Naim Core and the Innuos Zen Mini, there no longer appears to be a ‘reasonably’ priced ripper/server available……
.
Time to start brushing up on the NAS and media app skills then.
ATB, J
Isn’t the Stream series the new entry level?
The Innuos Stream 1 can have an external USB CD drive attached to rip discs.
£2100, cheaper than a Core, therefore by definition reasonable! 
Possibly, depends on how much you spend on the CD drive (Melco anyone?), pennies or pounds? (Other currencies are available 
).
ATB, J
We ripped many of our CDs using quite a generic USB CD drive from Amazon. £20.
It’s on the drive database for AccurateRip (Innuos demand the same) and was uber reliable. Read some badly damaged discs our CD player wouldn’t handle.
So total cost £2120 
I’ve been using an Apple Super Drive.. Works fine.
I don’t think the ripping is the problem. I can easily rip a cd using itunes with an inexpensive cd drive attached to my Mac. Works great.
The issue is the hassle of managing a server. That’s what made the Core so amazing. You get a device that
a) easily scales to large capacity (i have an 8tb drive in my mine)
B) can rip or you can load your already ripped cd’s and downloaded music easily
C) looks great and great buld quality
D) sounds great
E) requires near zero IT skill to manage
It is (E) that is the issue now with the Core discontinued. Am i going to have to manage a NAS myself and figure out how to connect it to my Dac? That is a hassle i do not need.
If you get a NAS it will be connected by Ethernet through your switch/router. They don’t (AFAIK) have S/PDIF outputs. Only (some) music servers e.g. Innuos Stream 1 will be able connect vis S/PDIF. Others have USB outputs e.g. Melco.
The Eversolo DMP series will do all of that plus room correction.
A normal NAS can’t connect direct to a DAC - rendering software is needed. A streamer such as Naim’s products includes a renderer and a DAC (and online streaming service access software), and accesses music stored on a NAS.
For tge OP:
At least some Melco and Innuos products have rendering software built in, as well as incorporating a music store so not needing a NAS and can play direct to DAC.
For the moderately computer savvy something like a Mac Mini running Audirvana (library and rendering software, also offering online streaming access) can do the same as those Innuos or Melco devices.
And a newish kid on the block is a Wiim Ultra, with attached hard drive or SSD, can do likewise. This may be the most budget friendly approach.
Whether or to what degree there are audible differences between these will depend hugely on the DAC, of course as well as the rest of the system including room, and your ears.
As has already been pointed out, ripping can be done on any computer with a CD drive eithrr internal or attached e.g. via USB.
BTW, unless you fill it and need more room there isn’t really any routine managing needed of a NAS other than doing backups to an external device, which is wise to do with any store - including Core.
Indeed, I run MinimServer on mine 
.
While the demise clearly hasn’t happened yet, a problem many manufacturers are facing is that optical drives for OEM are an increasing rarity with TEAC and Pioneer both leaving the optical drive (as opposed to single speed audio mech) market entirely. Those that remain are largely reserved for own brand products. For example Melco/Buffalo produce their own.
There are still some vendors like LG but the quality is dire (that word is’t strong enough sadly). So it leaves anyone who isn’t producing their own drives in a very difficult situation of scrambling for NOS or reverting to poor quality alternatives and attempting to design around those deficiencies.
I use roon, installing rock onto a pc is a breeze. The PC could cost 400 quid and still be awesome for the task and a lifetime roon subby and you are still quids in from 2k.
That’s why innovative vendors like Innuos have moved to supporting USB CD drives for ripping.
They don’t have to supply a drive, the user does. And the drive can be very cheap (£20) and still do a cracking job.
As long as the drive is on the AccurateRip drive list (which is extensive) it will be supported.
I rip all CDs with my MacBook and an external USB DVD player (less than 20€) in Flac with XLD.
Then put it on a little Samsung SSD, directly plug into the Nova.
(The Nova can be a server).
Simple and effective
PS: I also have a Nas with minimserver, but I prefer the SSD.
In the past I have an Aurender N100SC, and it detect the external USB DVD player. You can rip music on its internal SSD drive.
From memory the Uniti series were originally supposed to have this feature (Atom and Nova anyway) but it never appeared.
I have a melco in the system here and it seems quite happy ripping from the cheapest piece of crap usb cd drive I have.
So there you go.
This topic was automatically closed 60 days after the last reply. New replies are no longer allowed.
