Looking to buy my first turntable. Currently I own Naim Atom with Kef LS50s and two REL t5i subs.
I would like the turntable setup - TT, cartridge & phono - to match the source quality of the Atom.
Anybody has an idea what turntable would match the quality for the Atom’s digital source? I have been considering Rega P2, Pro-ject Carbon Debut and Technics SL-1500C.
This is tricky because vinyl never really matches what digital does, they’re just different. If possible I would seek out a Rega/Naim dealer and see if you could hear a Rega 2 through the Atom as that’s the only way you’ll get a feel for how they match up.
All the TTs you list are good it’s really just a matter of personal preference.
I think the SL-1500C will be far the best out of that bunch and fine for the Atom. It also includes a phono stage, but you might want to upgrade the cart at some point. If you’re willing to get a phono stage (I think you do as I don’t think the others include one), you might want to consider the SL-100C as it comes without one.
You can also consider vintage for some really good turntables and at great prices. I’ve currently got a Rega Planar 3 (90’s), a Heybrook TT2 and a Technics SP-10 (from an old radio station).
The Heybrook blows away the Rega and allows you to experiment with a wide variety of arms and cartridges. And if you get MM cartridges, replacement stylus from JICO are readily available and often better than the originals.
And the Technics is a whole other level!