Hi all,
Trying to decide between the Hi-CAP DR or a SuperCAP DR for my upcoming SN3 purchase. Any comments from folks with SN2’s or SN3’s who have compared them would be appreciated. Thank you.
Hi all,
Trying to decide between the Hi-CAP DR or a SuperCAP DR for my upcoming SN3 purchase. Any comments from folks with SN2’s or SN3’s who have compared them would be appreciated. Thank you.
If you can afford a SN3/SCdr, then you can do a 282/200 instead or 202/HCdr/200.
Tend to agree. If you could stretch to a 282/HC/250 for an extra 1k this would be the best option - unless you plan on using the phono stage of the SN.
Thank you. A friend who has tried both, said the SuperCap DR is “too much of a good thing” on his SN2.
Don’t know.
I doubt it’s too much of a good thing but to really exploit what SC can offer I’d be looking at a 282/200. In fact 282/200 (with 200 powering the 282) might be a more musical offering?
Good luck.
Lindsay
Thank you Lindsay.
I don’t know if the scdr is suitable for the Sn3.If you take a look at Naim website you will find, in the upgrade path box,only the HCDR.
It’s a waste of a Supercap IMHO. If this is the budget then a pre/power is the way to go.
I have Hicap DR with SN3, never compared with Supercap DR,but can say to my ears my CDX2 sounds great .
Get the SC DR. This future proofs your fun. Not to mention what a great power supply for a stageline of superline via the sn2/sn3. As one journeys through naim audio you upgrade amps and preamps but you keep SC’s. I couldn’t recommend owning a SC enough. Where applicable SC if possible!!
no need for a Supercap DR. While it will sound better than HCDR, the money is best spent on improving your source.
A SN doesn’t even accept the dual SNAIC connections from a SCDR as with a 282, does it? Seems a waste of a SCDR and not a very balanced purchase, or am I missing something?
The OP was hipcap dr vs Sc dr on a sn/3 Obviously wanting a smaller box count because he said that’s already decided, so why all the advice to buy a 282? The question is simple and answer is the Sc dr is better it sounds better whether your using 2 snaics or one it doesn’t matter . Being a Sc its flexible and future proofs the upgrades which will happen no doubt.
Thank you.
Because a Supercap is a lot of money, much more that a Hicap DR and may not be much better. It defeats the object really; why buy an integrated and then not use most of it??
282/200 is two boxes (ignoring the NAPSC which can be tucked away). Same as a SN3/power supply.
SC or not, if I knew from the outset it would be 2 boxes, I expect there is a good chance a 202/200 still might see off a SN3/SCdr for less money. The separation of preamp from both power supply and power amp has a lot to be said for it.
I love the idea of a top quality integrated. But to me, that appeal involves sticking with one box.
I have a Supernait2 with HiCap and love it. I was also curious about what the SuperCap could bring to my system.
Like anything, I know a demo in my own system would probably answer my question but it might not be easily done.
Is anyone here using or has tried a SuperCap on the Supernait2?
I’m still trying to understand what moving up the power supply ladder officially offers to a system.
Thank you all in advance.
No experience here, but since you’d only be using a single SNAIC with two supply lines I wouldn’t be surprised if a HICAP DR and SuperCapDR were indistinguishable.
Like others I’d agree a SuperCap is a useful thing to have though if you’re likely to change components in your system.
Agreed
The extra money for me is always better spent on a better source
Opening the window on a source by going from Hi cap to supercap still means you are listening to the same source !
I would rather have no Hicap DR at all and spend the money on a much better source.
This topic was automatically closed 60 days after the last reply. New replies are no longer allowed.