I am not so sure as both cables would appear to have similar inductance.
The figures that I could ascertain for each cable are -
NAC A4 Approximately 0.93 µH
NAC A5 approximately 1.0 µH/m nominal but measured to be 0.95 µH/m in 2019
I am not so sure as both cables would appear to have similar inductance.
The figures that I could ascertain for each cable are -
NAC A4 Approximately 0.93 µH
NAC A5 approximately 1.0 µH/m nominal but measured to be 0.95 µH/m in 2019
Neither was I until I tried. ![]()
I just had an itch to scratch for old times sake.
It’s a Vicks Sinex for your speakers. ![]()
I wish I had a pound for every time I’ve compared identical specifications and they sound very different. ![]()
I’m asking for the source of your information. Or what was your measurement methodology if you measured the inductance yourself?
It’s not really helpful when you just throw out an off-by 40% inductance claim as fact, absent of anything to back up your claim.
Are you now claiming that only NAC A4 falls short of the spec? You initially made the claim for “NACA4/5”.
As @highfell pointed out, NAC A4’s published inductance spec is 0.93µH/M.
In fact, here are all of the published electrical specifications for each that I’m aware of:
NAC A4
NAC A5
(I don’t know of a published resistance specification for A4, but if anyone knows, please jump in)
So regarding A4’s inductance specifically…
I just measured the loop inductance @ 1KHz on a NAC A4 cable using a DER DE-5000 inductance meter.
The result was 0.923 µH per metre.
Close enough as it’s tricky to get a precise inductance measurement with basic equipment.
Naim is well known for being very conservative with their specifications. i.e. “Naim watts”. Why would they inflate the NAC A4 (and/or NAC A5) inductance spec by 40%?
Just wondering - Did anyone claim that A4 and A5 sound the same? Or where you just taking the opportunity to mention that as a general principle?
I haven’t actually done any controlled comparison listening tests myself, so I have no idea. But I wouldn’t really expect them to sound exactly the same given all of the differences.
Thanks for your question. I should have been clearer. and I think the confusion centers around the difference between the minimum inductance in JV’s range and the actual inductance of NACA4/5. NACA4/5 doesn’t in any way “fall short” at least in the usual sense, it just happens to have a lower inductance than the minimum quoted in JV’s e-mail.
The smallest inductance quoted in JV’s range was 1.3microFarads per meter. For a 3m cable that produces a total inductance of 1.3x3=3.9microHenries. You have the same numbers I used for the Naim NACA4 specs; 0.93microHenries per meter; 3m of which would produce a total inductance of 3x0.93= 2.8microFarads. To get the same minimum total inductance (3.9miroFarads) you need 3mx3.9/2.8=4.2m. I didn’t distinguish between NACA4 and NACA5 since the inductance difference is small.
I see. You’re referring on JV’s note from 1998.
Yes, it would have been helpful if you had made it clear that you were comparing the inductance spec from that JV note vs the 1µH/M value now commonly stated for A5’s inductance.
I’m not sure what changed. Maybe JV measured it at a different frequency. Perhaps someone else knows more about A5’s history than I do.
In any case, for many years, A5’s inductance has generally been stated as 1 µH/m.
More importantly, it’s worth distinguishing the minimum length needed for stability—at least for the early generations of Naim amps—from the ideal length range for sound quality.
BTW, regarding:
The reason you needed 8m or 10m lengths of NACA (even though this was not particularly practical for many people) was probably because Naim used a stock cable that was made in larger quantities by a bulk cable manufacturer and employed primarily for another application. This was also almost certainly why NACA4 cable was quite inexpensive when launched.
Sorry - No. Naim A4/A5 speaker cable comes on reels, not in precut lengths of 8M or 10M.
Dealers can cut off whatever length they or the customer want. It is priced by the meter.
I stand by my actual words. ![]()
You are welcome to believe whatever you want to believe ![]()
I simply wanted to offer the facts as I understand them, for the benefit of others reading the forum.
I stand by my actual words.
Don’t sound very logical though if you ever owned some businesses and products. ![]()
Tamarin, my intent was the same. My concern, and why I posted the follow-up to the post containing JV’s e-mail, was that some people might assume that 3m of NACA4 or NACA5 would be sufficient to meet the total inductance stability criterion for older Naim amps. It doesn’t. It would be sufficient for some other a cable that had an inductance of 1.3microHenries per meter but it isn’t for NACA4 or NACA5. That is simply because of the fact that the Naim cables have a significantly lower inductance per meter than 1.3microHenries per meter.
Fair enough. But perhaps it would be more helpful to simply state that the current recommendation for NAC A4/A5 is to use a minimum length of 3.5M.
In any case, I think we’ve beaten this to death several times over, so I’ll leave it at that.
I see from your profile that you have a fabulous system. Just out of curiosity, which speaker cables do you use, and how long are they?
Thanks Tamarin, i am very lucky to own such a wonderful system and it has taken over 40 years to get to this point. I agree that we have beaten this one to death. Since you asked I use NACA4 which is what I have always used the Naim amps whether they were CB, Olive or now NC. I checked to be sure and I have 8m cables and previously I used slightly shorter cables of 5m length. I just got what was needed to fit with my listening area I had at the time; not because I felt there was any difference in sound quality between the two that I could hear.
Congratulations on your very fine system!
I use NAC A4 on both of my secondary Naim systems with mini monitor speakers, as NAC A5’s stiffness is very awkward with such small speakers.
I understand where you are coming from. It’s stiffness is a nuisance even with larger floorstanding speakers but unfortunately it is what it is. Sometimes I feel like I am dealing with an uncooperative boa constrictor.
Or a frozen garden hose
Well I decided to ask Naim. Are newer minimum lengths recommended based on the modern output stage spec alone or are different lengths listened to. I quote ‘The guidance is primarily down to to modern output stage topology, but specific numbers we suggest are absolutely vailidated through rigorous listening tests’
Thats good enough for me
There’s a section on Naim’s website about speaker cables, it comes under ‘Support and Maintenance’ / ‘Cable Quality and Performance’, this is what it says;
2. What Kind of Loudspeaker Cable Should I Use?
Naim recommends using Naim speaker cable, which is specifically designed to match the electrical characteristics of Naim amplifiers.
Whether A5 cable is better, equal to or worse in SQ terms than the dealer recommended Tellurium Black II I use is a mute point as it is too inflexible for my setup.
This ties in with wording in the manual for the Olive HiCap that I have just purchased.
In bold letters [Speaker Cables] - “They should be each at least 3.5M long and of equal length.”
Well said.
Also backed with historical reference by the designer:
Date: January 21, 1998 09:44 AM
Author: julian vereker
Subject: cable lengthThis has been covered before, (try search), but to restate, NACA was
designed for a nominal 10m length so that 5m - 20m would be fine, but
3m is the shortest recommended.julian