This is indeed a fascinating topic!! I’ve had the odd night where I struggle to connect with music, but fortunately no more than that. Some thoughts:
I think that streaming is wonderful but the “always everything” nature of it does reduce the degree to which music is valued. When you were younger I bet the struggled to buy all the music you wanted, this meant that when you did return home with a new record or CD you listened to it back to back for weeks until you were able to afford another one. With streaming everything you ever wanted to own is at your fingertips all the time and that can be both wonderful for discovery but also distracting.
Streaming encourages track by track browsing or playlist use whereas vinyl (and CD to a lesser extent) encourages you to listen to full albums as the artist intended. This just “is” more relaxing than what happens when you stream, which is you play a track and while playing it have to start thinking of the next track you need to tee up for the listening session. In my view this severely degrades your experience and emotional response and takes you out of the music. Also with vinyl(and to a lesser extent CD) it’s enjoyable to read the sleeve notes or lyrics along with the music and to savour the artwork - all of which pulls you in.
Yesterday a mate and I went to my local record shop and spent an hour or so picking out three albums at a total cost of £30 which we went home and played. Browsing the shelves and discussing albums with each other as we went was just so enjoyable, and that’s before we even got home, made a coffee and played them!! The whole collecting and owning element of vinyl in particular is deeply satisfying in a way that streaming just isn’t.
Finally one has a relationship and pride of ownership with a turntable that simply doesn’t exist with a streamer. Turntables are demanding of set-up, they require a degree of fettling, changes of arm, cartridge and even support surface make large differences to replay quality, whereas I find streamers are an appliance you can largely plonk down anywhere and get 90-100% performance right away without any special attention. Optimising a turntable is like spending 20 years learning piano before you’re able to play Rachmaninov properly, there’s simply no instant gratification and the journey is part of the fun.
You’ll note that nowhere here have I mentioned sound quality yet. That’s because a really good streamer like a yours or a NDX2 or NSS333 offers simply staggering levels of replay quality and only a top flight turntable can better them, and even then only sometimes. It wasn’t until I got to a GyroDec/SMEIV/Lyra Kleos SL into a £1500 phono stage that I truly felt my vinyl source could match or exceed the performance of my original NDX, let alone the NDX2. In truth I enjoy vinyl, CD and streaming so am format agnostic, however I do think that vinyl is often the most absorbing and engaging source as detailed above and it’s easier to become engrossed in a record played that way.
Finally I’d like to address the impact of environment. Listening in soft light or the dark, making sure you have a particularly comfy chair, maybe lighting a candle or burning some essential oils, opening a bottle of red or some single malt. All of these things can help to escape the cares of the day and help you become engrossed in the music. Set some time aside everyday just for music listening - no phones, no screens, no TV. As an example every single day the entire family know that 6-7pm is music replay time in our house (at the weekends this may be longer). I sit down and start playing music, my wife usually joins me and sometimes my 20 year old daughter will join us too. Anyone can contribute tracks and I’ve had heard some great music courtesy of my daughter in particular (and vice-versa).
When you’re young music is nearly always a social activity - you’d get together with mates to play music whereas when older it can end up being a somewhat solitary and lonely experience. In the past few years I have made a concerted effort to get together with people to listen - old school mates, my family, some hi-fi industry mates. I just invited the guy who runs my local secondhand vinyl shop around for a listen. Reach out and share music, make new discoveries that way and re-engage with the emotional resonance of music. Talk about it, read about it, read hi-fi reviews - heck read mine, there’s plenty of musical discoveries to be had in there - I spend half of every review talking about the technicalities and the other half talking about the music, how it sounds, how it makes me feel, how brilliant a particular album or artist is…
All of these things will help to preserve the magic. You have a fine system there - easily good enough to enjoy playing, food for thought I hope… Start today - it’s Saturday. Read some hi-fi reviews or buy a copy of a music magazine, then buy a candle, tell the family 6-7pm is music time tonight and invite them or a mate to join you. Pick an album you loved when you were 18 or 20 and you broke up with an ex girlfriend to! Or pick an album you remember enjoying with friends that made you happy. Have a read about it today, its background, how it was recorded and where. Then at 6pm pour a drink, dim the lights, close the curtains, banish the phones, gun the stereo to optimum listening level and just listen to it in its entirety beginning to end, read along to the lyrics, remember the times you listened to it at 2am sipping a bottle of bourbon in a seedy rented room pining over some broken love affair - you’ll feel it all again… That’s the power of music on good hi-fi, that’s why we do this, that’s why it matters… As I said in the review I wrote on the ATC speakers I have at home:
While we are on the subject of listening levels, the SCM40s are loudspeakers that really respond to volume. They performed well at low listening levels (and I’m thinking hotel-lobby Muzak levels here), but the sound really opened up as the volume rose. You don’t need to put yourself in the mosh pit at a Clash concert, but when listening to Kate Bush’s stunning debut album, The Kick Inside (CD, EMI Records EMC 3223), and the track of the same name, I found that a volume approximating the level of a live piano in the room achieved the best results. This is a gorgeously intimate and haunting recording, which has virtually no instrumentation apart from Bush’s voice and her piano. The ATCs projected her soaring teenage vocals deep into the room with extraordinary levels of expression and sensuality. There was a feeling of boundless dynamic range and a vividly lifelike quality to her voice that sent shivers up my spine. There’s a line in this song where Bush sings “I’m giving it all, giving it, giving it, giving it,” at which point she strikes the next piano chord with dramatic ferocity. On lesser systems, this searing intensity isn’t fully realized—there’s compression and a lack of attack to the notes—but with the ATCs I found myself pinned to the seat, near rigid with emotion. It’s moments like this that make all the years of saving and sacrifice, all the faffing about with cables and worrying about dedicated AC wiring, utterly worthwhile. In these musical moments it all makes perfect sense; and you realize, while sitting in your favorite chair and listening to Kate Bush pouring her heart out to you so intimately, that your eyes are full of tears.
JonathanG
Oh and while I think of it check out a couple of fantastic movies about music that perfectly evoke what it felt like to be 18-20 and to love music so much:
-
“God help the Girl” - this film is an absolute joy and has a fab soundtrack and screenplay by Stuart Murdoch of Belle and Sebastian fame. Subtle, romantic, nuanced, beautiful and nostalgic. It’s a love letter to how it feels to be 20 and to be in love, but to never be able to find quite the right moment or words to say to the gal… If you want to be reminded of your tongue tied hapless former self just watch it!! The ending still makes me cry and I must be on my 10th viewing!!
-
“Sing Street” - A thoroughly engaging, funny and brilliantly written movie about that classic trope of dreaming of being a rock star and again falling in love for the first time. Fab soundtrack too!!
Heck put them on after the music hour tonight - they’re eminently suitable for all ages and all genders…