Good morning everyone. I am really loving the sound of my system at the moment. If I had any sense I’d leave well alone and just enjoy the music. Unfortunately I am afflicted by a persistent desire to tweak. What if I were to do this or that? (I imagine one or two of you are similarly afflicted?)
Which brings me to today’s question. After talking to audiophile buddies and doing a bit of reading round the subject I have come to the conclusion that my phono stage (ProJect Tube Box S2) is the weak link in my analogue system. And after a bit more research I have come up with a shortlist of potential replacements: -
ProJect Tube Box DS2.
Rega Aria
Gold Note PH-5
I tend to prefer a warm, rich sound to an (over?) analytical one. It is not going to be easy to audition a direct comparison of these in my area. So I wondered if any of you guys have experience of any of these phono stages. And, particularly, if you have had the opportunity to directly compare them. I’d love to hear what you think.
I have two PH10’s and would recommend the PH5 just on that basis. The PH5 also can be enhanced by the addition of the separate psu 5. The ability to change the setting for both cartridge impedance and gain without dip switches is worth it alone. Excellent construction and the control via impedance and gain on the front panel allows you to fine tune on the fly.
Yes I have thought about trying some tube rolling. I may try that before actually replacing my phono stage. Or I might get the DS2 and THEN try some tube rolling. All options are on the table at the moment.
I’m in a similar boat, moving from the built in phono stage in my 222 to a standalone phono stage, after looking at the Rega Aria or Aos I have decided that I’m going for Vertere’s Phono-1 LX. My HiFi Guru rates the Vertere highly, it allows me to keep the Hana MH that I have but then allows me the option of MC or MM when I come to change cartridge in a few years time.
The Rega Aria is very good but from my listening not as good as the Aos but that is MC only and for me would have meant swapping carts and extra expense, the Vertere just gave me a listening experience that was better than the Aria, one that I enjoyed a lot, plus it gives me the flexibility to decide in the years ahead which direction I want to go with my cartridge.
I did hear the PH5 but that was a while back and not as a comparison with the Rega’s or Vertere, it was an enjoyable listen.
I did some auditioning of phono stages about a year ago. The one I liked the most was Vertere and I felt it was good value for money at the time. Nothing wrong with Rega’s product but I didn’t like the presentation (many people love it).
Rega Aria is now end of life. Perhaps you are looking at old dealer stock or ex-demo?
The Aria is a great all rounder - both MM and MC - and well regarded
Maybe consider the latest Rega Aos MC instead.
Thank you all for your insight and suggestions. I guess I need to try and organise some auditions now. I might try a spot of tube rolling while a think about it!