Probably a basic question. The BBC has announced that R4 Extra will only be available online. It’s not only 4Extra but that’s the one that concerns me.
After the BBC implement their changes will 4Extra still be available on iradio on Naim devices? That’s “online” I believe? TIA
Not sure, I suggest the typical R4 listener now uses a ‘smart’ speaker for radio at least in part… and BBC Sounds is the default way of listening to BBC Radio on many if not most smart speakers,… perhaps one of the reasons that prompted the move as a way to save money.
The content is nearly all archive material, so the cost is significantly distribution, and a radio broadcasting station is hugely more expensive than being an online station.
As long as they keep retrieving interesting archive stuff and put it on Sounds, I will be happy. I find much of the content these days on R4 main channel eminently missable.
I refuse to have a speaker which is smarter than me in the house. It is bad enough having two calculating cats running the show, I don’t need a speaker assisting them.
I’d suggest that anyone who listens to BBCR4 Extra makes a note of programmes they generally listen to. The BBC Sounds App works well, you can search by title and there are various categories. You can listen on your phone, like a millennial, or you can use Bluetooth to send the programme to many modern radios, such as the retro Roberts radio. (Many other brands of Bluetooth radio are available.) It isn’t necessary to have the kind of smart speaker that is voice controlled, or to voice control your phone. I hope this helps.
Taking everyones’ helpful comments and suggestions on board (thank you) it seems to me this boils down to the loss of 4 Extra as a radio station. We put it on as background whilst doing chores around the house or cooking and we don’t like what’s on Radio 4. Looking for programmes on Sounds and using airplay or bluetooth to put in on the kitchen Muso2 is very do-able but it’s more of a faff. And when that programme ends it’s time to browse Sounds again. One of the things I like about radio is that I find myself listening to stuff I wouldn’t have sought out but find is good when it just happens.
Still, it’s a minor thing and probably we’ll find content on Sounds that we wouldn’t known about.
My experience of bbc sounds is not as good as @Stokie. Especially as I like the randomness of 4x; searching for genres is ok but I like the curated feel of 4x that sounds does not have. I suppose it’s not the end of the world.
When BBC Sounds App replaced IPlayer Radio in 2018, I didn’t like using it, but subsequent versions have worked rather better. You can subscribe to a series and your feed will update. Some series follow a particular programme: the Hugh Bonneville reading of Sherlock Holmes is a sequence. Other series are more varied ‘Sound of Cinema’ pops up when I searched for ‘Holmes.’ The smart aspect appears to be that the App tracks your usage. You can see more episodes and listen or skip. I use Sounds every day, so I get plenty of practice using it.
BBC Radio 4 Extra is being turned off. Some content will be made avaiable on BBC Sounds as programmes. I can use bluetooth to send Sounds content from my phone to other devices. So not the same as the radio station.
I suspect the suits want to build a younger audience base. BBC4 Extra contains many programmes I heard when I was a child from the mid 50s to 60s. Some brilliant, though then above my head like Round the Horne others that now seem dated. Radio 4’s ‘Feedback’ will have senior executives responding to the closing of 4 Extra.
It’s more a spoken word station Neil. Content is from the vast BBC archives - so they don’t need to produce any new material. But it’s typical listener is an older person and the BBC is trying to connect with younger age groups.