After purschsing a NAC 272 early this year the opportunity has come alomg to buy a second hand XP5XS powersuply at about 40% of new price.
Before listening i would like to know how much of a benefit the powersuply will deliver in relation to the XPS/XPS and to the NAC 272 Itself.
Main question is will the XP5XS hold up against the XPS relative in price.
I tried an XP5XS when I first got a 272, which I no longer have, and thought there was no real upside at all to using it. No way I would get one, just use the built in supply until you can afford an XPSDR or a 555DR.
Setting aside sound quality I’d pass on the XP5XS for two reasons - it was never intended for the 272, rather for the ND5xs, and being discontinued and with limited use now the new ND5XS2 cannot use a power supply it will be hard to sell for a decent price should you want something better at a later date.
I would keep saving for an XPSDR or 555PSDR. Both will give a very meaningful improvement and will hold their value a lot better.
The NAC-N 272 combines our latest innovations in digital audio technology with classic analogue preamplifier engineering. It samples the best of both worlds to create an immensely musical hi-fi system.
Paired with a NAP 200, NAP 250 or even a NAP 300 power amplifier, the 272 is an ideal choice for those seeking the convenience of a single box streaming system with iOS and Android app control, but that crave hi-fi separates performance. It boasts an impressive array of inputs including high-resolution (up to 24bit/192kHz) UPnPTM streaming, Spotify Connect, iRadio, Bluetooth (aptX), USB, multiroom, TIDAL music streaming support and an optional DAB/FM module. Six digital and three analogue inputs cover integration with a wide range of sources from CD and games consoles to phonostages. It’s also performance upgradable with the addition of a Naim Audio XP5 XS, XPS or 555 PS power supply.
All this functionality does not come at the cost of performance. The 272 has been carefully designed and meticulously hand-crafted to deliver a completely immersive and awe-inspiring music experience.
This is clearly out of date information, and misleading to anyone who is unaware of the Naim range of streamers. If fact, I think it might be prudent of @NaimAdmin to rewrite it.
@Hifiman: the unit for sale has a asking price off £975/€1100( Exchange rates in mind as i live in the Netherlands). Wich is about 60% less than the latest selling price and about 75/80% less than a new XPSdr.
@anon4489532: did you try a XPS(dr) powersuply on your NAC 272?
I’ve read somewhere on the internet that the XP5XS has about 80% off the sound quality off a XPS powersuply (on a nd5xs player) is that about right?
Would that percentage make a huge difference on the NAC 272 as it will power the pre-amp section as well?
The thing is i’ve only had the NAC 272 for a short while so i won’t be trading it in soon. Also there are second to none used XPR’s availeble over here, but i guess there will be a reason for that .
The DR version is a lot better. An upgrade to DR will cost €2,399 excluding VAT from September, so you need to think about how much the non DR model costs and take into account whether you will want to upgrade later. A DR upgraded 555 will be the same as an original 555DR.
Hifiman: there wasn’t/isn’t a budget, there is some upgrading room, just not new XPS dr kind of money.
The ball began to roll when the used xp5xs showed up on a second hand sales site, which seemed a reasonable upgrade.
After all of your advise/reactions, including those of hungryhalibut and ChrisSU, questions started to pop up. I guess I am at a difficult crossroad indeed .
The most sensible thing to do seems to save up some penny’s (or Euro’s) and go for a XPSdr. Also based on the discussion in the 250dr to 300dr topic where the dr versions of the powersupply’s seem to have more drive etc.