I have to say I also have a soft spot for the Chandos version sung by much missed Felicity Lott who died earlier this year. Less opulent, but just as compelling in its own way.
@PeakMan Thanks Roger. I have a memory that Elisabeth Schwarzkopf selected all her own recordings for Desert Island Discs, but I’ll certainly listen to her.
I think seven of the eight she chose were of her own recordings. Not very British! Perhaps best just to enjoy the performance, or listen to Dame Felicity who was, by all accounts, widely admired and loved. A thoroughly good person as well as a very fine singer.
Häkkinen’s Art of the Fugue is by some margin the finest recording I have of the work. The harpsichord is not an instrument that sells itself easily, I think, but this is one of those recordings where everything comes together.
Janet Baker as Dido gets to the heart of this mini opera like no other performance that I’ve heard. Right from the start she knows how this tragedy is going to work out and it’s there in Baker’s voice. When it gets to the famous Lament and particularly her rendition of “remember me” she sends shivers down the spine like no other. A true gramophone classic.
When Hurwitz calls something nauseating, that’s actually a ringing endorsement. I collected these recordings over the years and then added the boxset because of the classy presentation. They are great.
Last night, I listened to Pappano’s Turandot from a few years ago. It’s truly excellent, in many ways as good as any of the famous classics. But that ending… this has the original finale by Franco Alfano, which before the premiere was abbreviated by Toscanini who felt it was too crass and loud. The long version heard here is dramatically slightly more coherent but Turandot’s conversion to a good girl is still as believable as Anakin Skywalker’s fall to the dark side. And Alfano’s music is, frankly, monotonous, loud and boring. Toscanini was right.
I had a listen to one of the discs after watching that review. It wouldn’t be my number one choice but it had a lot of good stuff and certainly didn’t merit the walloping that Hurwitz gave it. Just seems like click bait to me.
Danny Driver combines two masterworks for an inspired recital. Driver always sounds in confident control, and has a wonderfully recorded Steinway. A surprise entry for record of the year for me.