7%
1 Like
Not counting connectors/cablesā¦
Source: XPS DR > NDX 2 = 36.3%
Amplification: HiCap DR > NAC 282 > NAP 250 DR = 43.2=3%
Speakers: ProAC D30RS = 20.4 %
@Blackbird ā Not to sure I would put much stock in Paulās approach. Could you ask Paul and post a sample or two of what he would propose is a balanced system he would sell?
3 Likes
I donāt have any connections with Mr Paul 
Paul is the CEO and founder of PS Audio in the US. PS Audio manufactures mainly same components as Naim does but has just entered the speaker market so they have no interest in selling speakers only. You can find the videos he post almost daily on their Youtube channel. Iām not in any camp here, just curios on how members here have spent their money 
3 Likes
I donāt spend any time on the Youtube channel. I did take a quick glance at the PS Audio site but did not see any articles posted by Paul that is why I asked if you had any examples from your source material.
No worries, this topic has been discussed in the past.
Nail on the head there Lindsay. Getting the balance right is the thing. I think people get too hung up on spending 25% on this and 40% on that. If the system gels it doesnāt really matter!
4 Likes
12% here lol
1 Like
It is really a wrong way to ask the question. Of course if you have a low budget and donāt plan any future upgrades (say a total of up to 1500Ā£ for the whole system) you should spend as much as you can on the speaker which works in your room.
For everything above a certain threshold i feel that there is not real way to answer this question in numbers - nor does it really matter.
You may also have a look here for an overview:
1 Like
Around 8/9 % here.
Around 7% (pre-loved prices) for me. I forgot to factor in my subwoofer earlier, so have deleted that post of 3%.
With the powerlines, hiline and Morgana cables Iāve almost spent as much on cables as I did on the speakers 
1 Like
As others have pointed out, thereās an enormous assumption that youāre budgeting to buy one system all in one go with no upgrades ever. Now, I suppose there must be people that do that, but I donāt think there are many of them on this forum.
Be that as it may, Iāve just broken down the cost of my system (all secondhand but bought in stages with various trade-ins, the value of which Iām ignoring in these calculations) as:
Source: 18%
Amplification (including NAPSC): 29%
Speakers: 39%
Ancillaries (NACA5, FraimLite etc): 14%
I suppose that makes it a mullet, does it?
Mark
Your speaker percentage would be higher if you had spent less on Ethernet cables 
Seriously though at the level of electronics we have this guy is advocating 50k speakers. Whilst great speakers must be an ambition for all (and indeed can substantially change the listening experience) source/pre must surely be priorities.
If itās not coming out of the amp how can speakers present it.
1 Like
Iāve not seen the video yet, however if you see size of speakers he generally shows, then its not surprising. Also being in the US, I would think they would cater for much larger rooms than the UK, so perhaps we are comparing apples with pears
Everything is bigger in Texas 
My source alone is nearly 50% of the budget in my system. It sounds fantastic. Iāve built systems backwards in the past. For me itās not anywhere near as musically satisfying. Iām now a convert of the source first approach. Like you say, nothing can really be fixed at the back-end of the system. Whatās already lost is lost.
P.S And then you change something as little as a Ethernet or an interconnect cable and BOOM. There it is!
3 Likes
If the CDX2 was still in production today it would probably cost about Ā£5k, so a similar price to your amp and not much less than your speakers. So no, not that much of a mullet really.
1 Like
Just showed SWMBO Dynaudio Confidence 60, which would take speaker spend to ~50%. They received the same cold shoulder as my current favs (ATC SCM50 passive). So the list of āgood lookingā lounge friendly candidates so far is SF Olympica Nova or Kudos 606s. 25%.
Sometimes speaker ambitions and hence % spend are limited by domestic harmony.
5 Likes
Donāt know and donāt care, plus canāt be asked to work it out.
It sounds good and thatās all that matters, says the guy thatās about to potentially change his speakers Wednesday
2 Likes